Should you display customer reviews on your product business’s Shopify Website?

For Designers


I'm a brand and website designer for bold, play-outside-the-box businesses and a mentor for creative entrepreneurs wanting to keep their creative spark while growing their business.


Hey, I'm

Work with me

Picture of a woman on the red telephone in context to leaving reviews on a product business website

Today, let’s talk about a game-changer in the world of e-commerce and why, despite its incredible potential, some businesses still get the jitters when it comes to displaying customer reviews on their websites.

As a seasoned Shopify website designer and expert, I’m here to walk you through the immense value of displaying those glorious reviews on your website. We’ll also address the all-too-common jitters that businesses experience and offer a more empowering alternative.

Ready? Let’s roll!

Picture this: you’re on the hunt for the perfect foundation. You hop onto a makeup brand’s website and find a section teeming with reviews from people who’ve already tried the product. Are you more likely to click “Add to Cart” than if you were flying blind? Ummmm, yes please.

Customer reviews aren’t just random words on a webpage; they’re a diverse collection of real experiences( yes- even the not so glowing ones!) that guide potential buyers toward confident purchasing decisions.

Customer reviews inject authenticity into your brand’s online presence. They’re like real-life success stories that shout, “Hey, we’re not just tooting our own horn!” When potential customers stumble upon genuine experiences shared by people just like them, a sense of trust starts building.

Why Customer Reviews Are Worth Their Weight in Gold

  1. Trust Factor: Think about it—when your buddy recommends a new restaurant, you’re more likely to give it a shot, right? The same principle applies to online shopping. Reviews from real customers act as trust-building badges, telling your visitors, “Hey, we’re legit!”
  2. Social Proof: Human beings are inherently social creatures. We like to know what others are doing before we dive in. Customer reviews provide that much-needed social proof, showing that others have taken the plunge and loved it.
  3. Feedback + Market Research Avenue: Ever wondered what your customers truly think about your offerings? Customer reviews offer a direct line to their thoughts. You can identify strengths, areas for improvement, and even get ideas for new products.
  4. SEO Stardom: Here’s a little secret: Google loves customer reviews. Positive or not, they’re like gold nuggets for search engine optimization Reviews, particularly if peppered with relevant keywords, can work wonders for your website’s visibility on search engines. Plus, each review adds fresh content to your website, making it more appealing to search engines. Plus, when potential customers search for your products or services, those shiny stars (aka ratings) might just catch their eye, increasing the likelihood of a click.
  5. Conversion Catalyst: Imagine this: someone is this close to buying your tantalizing scented candle but needs a gentle nudge. Positive reviews can be the nudge that turns a hesitant browser into a delighted buyer.

Let’s talk about the jitters:

Now, let’s tackle the elephant in the room: why do some businesses shy away from displaying customer reviews?

What if the reviews aren’t all sunshine and rainbows? What if a single negative comment tarnishes their online reputation forever?

Dread of Negative Reviews

Ah, the dreaded negative review. We get it—it’s like a mini thunderstorm on your parade. But here’s the thing: negative reviews are an opportunity in disguise. They showcase your willingness to accept feedback and improve.

Plus, a bunch of five-star reviews can sometimes raise eyebrows, making authenticity questionable.

Loss of Control

Businesses, especially those just finding their digital feet, often fear the loss of control over their brand image. But remember, customer reviews are a reflection of your brand’s real interactions, not your meticulously curated marketing messages. The beauty lies in the unfiltered nature of these reviews, which customers appreciate.

Embrace this authenticity—it’s the golden ticket to genuine connections.

The ‘Too Good to Be True’ Paradox

A barrage of glowing reviews might seem fishy to the savvy consumer. But here’s the kicker: authenticity shines through diversity. Different voices, different experiences—it all adds up to a real and relatable picture. Plus, a mix of reviews, both positive and constructive, actually underscores your legitimacy.

What to Do Instead: Embrace Transparency and Learning

Now that we’ve dissected the reasons behind the hesitations, let’s delve into the empowering alternative approach that businesses should adopt:

1. Embrace the Imperfections

Acknowledge that no business is perfect, and that’s perfectly fine! Customer reviews that highlight areas for improvement show that you’re open to growth. Your transparency will earn respect and loyalty from customers who value authenticity.

2. Respond with Care

Negative reviews are a goldmine of insights. Address them with grace and a genuine desire to make things right. When potential customers see your commitment to resolving issues, they’ll trust you even more.

3. Spotlight Constructive Critiques

Turn customer feedback into an opportunity for product enhancement. Share how you’ve taken action based on previous reviews. This demonstrates your dedication to offering the best possible experience.

In Conclusion: Customer reviews, Yay or Nay?

Definately, one big Yay!!

As a Shopify website designer and expert, I’ve seen businesses flourish when they embrace customer reviews as a trust-building strategy. It’s like inviting your customers to co-create your success story.

So, don’t let fear hold you back. Instead, let authenticity be your guiding star.

Encourage reviews, respond thoughtfully, and turn every piece of feedback into a stepping stone toward improvement.

Remember, trust is the currency of the digital age.

Display those reviews proudly, and watch as your online store transforms into a thriving hub of trust, loyalty, and growth. Here’s to building a business that shines with the brilliance of genuine customer experiences!



PS: We’re all about transparency, so we want to give you a heads up. This blog post is like a treasure hunt, sprinkled with a few affiliate links that might catch your eye. What does that mean? Well, if you happen to click on one of these links and decide to make a purchase, I might earn a tiny commission. Don’t worry, though – it won’t cost you an extra dime! It’s just a little virtual high-five for sending some love our way.

Rest assured, we’re not here to play matchmaker with products that don’t jive with your style. Our recommendations are rooted in genuine enthusiasm for stuff I think is pretty darn awesome.



How To Manage Your Energy During Your Launch


Increase your conversions by adding a quiz to your website


My exact practice for anchoring big beliefs in business


Don’t miss these reader favorites

Craft a product page 
 that sells! 




5 Common mistakes you might be making- and what to do instead! 

A quick checklist of the sections that help you convert window shoppers into buyers! 

Real examples of some beautiful + high converting product pages (that are also build to help your customers fall in love with your brand!)